Won't You Be My Neighbor?
Now for something G-Rated: Below is some archived footage of Fred Rogers before a Senate Committee meeting on funding of public television
I disagree with the premise of public television. Mr, Rogers, Sesame Street and Barney can easily survive in the public sector; and PBS is now thoroughly obsolete with the dozens of learning channels and kids channels on cable. The "bombardment" which Rogers lamented ended up being only a temporary situation remedied by new technologies and media which gave kids and parents better choices of entertainment. Whether parents made those better choices, and avoided worse choices, is another controversy.
Nonetheless, Rogers' motivation was admirable, to create wholesome relation-based children shows at the height of the "Itchy and Scratchy" era of violent kids' shows. To teach kids not to fight and have temper tantrums, but to use their words.
Fred Rogers appears to have won. Children's shows emphasizing relationships and getting along are common, while kid's cartoons about two animals trying to kill each other have fallen out of style. Yet has child's programming really gotten better? Why are grownups comfortable with Elmer and Bugs and Tom and Jerry and G.I. Joe and Cobra Commander, yet weirded out by cartoons like these?
I disagree with the premise of public television. Mr, Rogers, Sesame Street and Barney can easily survive in the public sector; and PBS is now thoroughly obsolete with the dozens of learning channels and kids channels on cable. The "bombardment" which Rogers lamented ended up being only a temporary situation remedied by new technologies and media which gave kids and parents better choices of entertainment. Whether parents made those better choices, and avoided worse choices, is another controversy.
Nonetheless, Rogers' motivation was admirable, to create wholesome relation-based children shows at the height of the "Itchy and Scratchy" era of violent kids' shows. To teach kids not to fight and have temper tantrums, but to use their words.
Fred Rogers appears to have won. Children's shows emphasizing relationships and getting along are common, while kid's cartoons about two animals trying to kill each other have fallen out of style. Yet has child's programming really gotten better? Why are grownups comfortable with Elmer and Bugs and Tom and Jerry and G.I. Joe and Cobra Commander, yet weirded out by cartoons like these?








0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home